Widmann v. Pateman

Supreme Court, State of New York,

County of Putnam

Case No. 500221/2021

2021 - Hon. Victor Grossman

2022 - Hon. Thomas Davis

2023, 2024, 2025 - Hon. Victor Grossman

Erika M. Widmann,

Plaintiff

v.

Charlene A. Pateman a/k/a Charlene A. Schroeder,

Defendant

In 2021, I became the defendant in a civil lawsuit filed by a former business associate, Erika M.  Widmann, who claimed breach of contract despite failing to provide valid documentation or fulfill her own obligations. Over the course of four years, the case dragged on through procedural delays, changing attorneys, and what I believe was coordinated harassment under the guise of legal process.

Despite my efforts to resolve matters respectfully and outside of court, I was forced to defend myself through countless court appearances, at great personal and financial cost. Key objections were repeatedly overruled, while improper evidence and actions by the plaintiff and her supporters were allowed without accountability.

This case reflects more than a contract dispute. It exposes a troubling pattern of bias, intimidation, and systemic failure that has affected not only my business but my well-being.

The court ruled against me in this case. I am currently appealing the decision and preparing a formal record to correct what I believe is a miscarriage of justice. What I’ve written here is my opinion about the outcome, shared for awareness and discussion. (see full disclaimer)

Current Status: On appeal before the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division – Second Department (covering the 9th and 10th Judicial Districts).
Lower Court: Putnam County Supreme Court
Index No.: 500221/2021
Appellate Docket No.: 2025-05063